President Linda Duncan called the meeting to order at 3:30 P.M. Twenty senators were present. Senator Richard Balderas was absent.
1. Approval of Minutes and Treasurer's Report.
Upon motion by Richard Winton, the Senate approved the minutes
of the February 8 meeting. The Treasurer reported a balance of
$2,215.05.
2. Report on Provost's Meeting.
President Duncan reported on the following topics relative to
her most recent meeting with the Provost:
A. Proposed Change in the Faculty and Staff Handbook:
At its November 9 meeting, the Faculty Senate passed the following
proposed revision to the Faculty and Staff Handbook:
The Tarleton State University Faculty Senate has the responsibility
for suggesting, reviewing, and commenting on all additions and
revisions to the Tarleton State University Handbook for Faculty
and Administrative Staff pertaining to general academic policies,
faculty welfare, and faculty rules of procedure on a timely basis
(1) before any such additions or revisions are approved by the
President, (2) before such additions and revisions are referred
to the Texas A&M University System or legal council for approval,
and (3) before any additions or revisions are incorporated into
the Tarleton State University Handbook for Faculty and Administrative
Staff.
Duncan shared the Provost's emailed response to this proposal
in which the Senate's statement was amended to read as follows:
The Tarleton State University Faculty Senate is the faculty representative
council on campus and therefore should advise the administration
regarding all substantive changes in and additions to the rules
and regulations found in the Handbook for Faculty and Administrative
Staff with a specific focus on general academic policies, faculty
welfare, and faculty rules of procedure.
Following a lengthy discussion during which several senators expressed
the belief that the Provost's wording might substantially weaken
the senate's proposed revision, Gene Atkinson moved to instruct
President Duncan to submit the following revised Senate statement:
The Tarleton State University Faculty Senate has the responsibility
for suggesting, reviewing, and commenting on additions and revisions
to the Tarleton State University Handbook for Faculty and Administrative
Staff pertaining to general academic policies, faculty welfare,
and faculty rules
of procedure on a timely basis before any additions or revisions
are incorporated into the Tarleton State University Handbook for
Faculty and Administrative Staff.
The motion passed unanimously.
B. Tarleton On-Line Evaluations.
The Provost reported that he had checked with legal counsel for
the Texas A&M System regarding the legality of posting the
results of faculty evaluations on-line and learned that such results
are considered to be public record and may be posted on the Internet.
C. Developmental Leave Policy.
The Provost reported that he supports the idea of faculty developmental
leave, but is not sure what final form it should take.
D. Sick Leave Policy.
Duncan expressed concern that university sick leave policy is
still not being interpreted consistently across campus. By general
consensus, the Senate agreed with her proposal to invite Dr. Alexander
and Angie Brown to the April meeting to clear up lingering confusion.
3. Report on Texas Council of Faculty Senates Meeting.
Attendees of the February 25-26 Texas Council of Faculty Senates
meeting reported on the following topics of interest and concern:
Linda Duncan: (1) On-line evaluation of faculty. (2) Administrative
policies and procedures that prevent faculty communication with
members of the press.
Gene Atkinson: (1) Similarity of faculty concerns in all universities.
(2) Lack of unanimity toward legislative priorities.
Bill Beaty: K-16 "seamless" education for Texas.
Teresa Davidian: (1) Tarleton's progress report contained less
"boosterism" than those of other universities. (2)
Reports from other universities of student disruptions in classrooms.
(3) The competitive threat from community colleges.
4. Report from Faculty Evaluation Committee.
Holly Lamb distributed copies of a proposed faculty evaluation
form, which her committee developed to improve the instrument
currently being used. She acknowledged the contributions of Kim
Rynearson to these changes. Lamb reported the committee hopes
ultimately to develop a form containing questions and responses
on a single sheet with provisions for written comments on the
same form. President Duncan asked senators to take these proposed
changes back to their departments and solicit faculty input.
Following further discussion in April, the final vote on this
committee's proposals will be made at the May meeting.
5. Report from O. A. Grant Award Committee.
Gene Atkinson noted that the Tarleton Alumni Society agrees with
the Senate that potential problems exist regarding the awarding
of the O. A. Grant Award to Jack and Louise Arthur Award nominees
who did not win the award in the previous year. He noted that
Tarleton will continue to follow this format in the current year
but will adopt a new policy in the future. Atkinson stated that
the Alumni Society will set nomination and election criteria for
this award in coming years without direct input from the Faculty
Senate.
6. Selection of Jack and Louise Arthur Award Nominees.
The senate members selected Loretta Brister, Stephen Field, and
Chris Guthrie as their nominees for the Jack and Louise Arthur
Award. College appointees for the final selection committee appear
as follows: Arts and Sciences - Phil Sudman, Education and Fine
Arts - Thomas Dougherty, Business Administration - Dan Dudley,
Graduate - David Weissenburger, Agriculture and Technology - Sandy
Johnson.
7. Report on Meetings with Student Government Association regarding
TOLE.
President Duncan reported that she had met with Elvis Moya and
the president of the Student Government Association (SGA). She
noted the attitude of this organization has matured during this
process. Moya has reviewed the Faculty Evaluation Committee's
proposed changes to the evaluation form and is supportive of these
changes. David Weissenburger observed that Tarleton, Central
Texas faculty members were not included in the SGA's recent survey
regarding on-line evaluation. Leslie Stanley-Stevens noted some
Humanities Building faculty members were excluded as well. President
Duncan reported the SGA plans to implement TOLE in January or
September of 2001. In response to Duncan's question regarding
the advisability of inviting Moya to appear before the Senate,
most members believed it was too early in the planning process
for this step to be beneficial.
8. Discussion of Coordinating Board's New Higher Education
Plan.
President Duncan appointed the following committee to determine
three major goals of higher education and to suggest means of
achieving those goals at the May meeting:
Janis Petronis, Business Administration, Chair
Charles Walker, Arts and Sciences
Randy Hines, Agriculture and Technology
Teresa Davidian, Education and Fine Arts
Karen Defranchi, Library
David Weissenburger, Central Texas
9. Contribution to Annual Faculty and Staff Picnic.
Following a brief discussion, Sandy Johnson moved to contribute
$250 to the annual Faculty and Staff Picnic. The motion passed
unanimously.
10. New Business.
David Weissenburger indicated he has questions regarding the Texas
A&M System's new policy on intellectual property. Charles
Walker agreed and moved to include the issue as an agenda item
in the April meeting. During the ensuing discussion, Gene Atkinson
noted the University of North Texas recently adopted a new intellectual
property policy regarding on-line courses, and he will bring that
policy statement to the April meeting. Walker's motion passed
unanimously.
President Duncan adjourned the meeting at 4:55 P.M.