From Making Meaning: Inference and Rhetoric in the Interpretation of Cinema



Bordwell's Four Ways of Making Meaning

David Bordwell, in Making Meaning: Inference and Rhetoric in the Interpretation of Cinema, argues that when we interpret films, we construct meanings in only four possible ways:

Bordwell's Schema Applied to "Closet Land"

The Referential 

(a constructed version of the diegesis and fabula) 

The Explicit 

(a conceptual "point") 

The Implicit (Symbolic) 

The Repressed or Symptomatic 

The totalitarian state 

The abusive father 

The family; "law of the father" 

Hegemonic patriarchy; imperialism; colonialism 

The interrogator 

The child abuser 

The Patriarch 

Agents of totalizing narratives 

Coerced involvement 

AB234 

The tongueless whistler 

AB234

Woman 

girl-child 

Marginalized others; the oppressed 

The confession; state-sanctioned interpretation 

AB234's recognition and recollection 

Totalizing discourses; grand narratives 

Determined, subjected, subject positions 

AB234 (politically unaware) 

The duplicitous mother 

The feminized and duplicitous masses 

Duplicitous Spectators 

The Torture chamber 

The Closet in AB234's home 

The home as the hidden, concealed site of abuse 

the "disappeared" 

"Closet Land" as political discourse 

"Closet Land" as children's book 

feminine discourse; imaginative discourse; 
literary discourse

Subversive discourse 

AB234 (politically aware) 

AB234 (psychological aware) 

"empowerment" 

Politically aware spectators 

Victim "victorious" over victimizer 

Human rights violations 

child abuse 

unconcealment 

activism


Discussion


Nick Lilly
lilly@vms.tarleton.edu